comic books

Superman #51 Review: What’s going to happen to New 52 Superman?

superman 51 review spoilers

Apparently Superman can’t catch a break in his movies or his comics. Superman #51 kicked off the Super League crossover event, and it was quite the dramatic beginning. So let’s discuss Superman #51!

Spoilers follow.

We know that DC are planning their next big change, with Rebirth getting ready to launch in June. They have kept a lot of things close to their chest, including what’s happening with Superman.

Superman #51 opens with the revelation that Superman is dying. From the panels we know that this issue takes place after the events of Darkseid War and JSA. He’s been through a lot, so really it’s not surprising that he’s dying.

Similarly to All-Star Superman, Superman wants to make sure that after he dies that Earth will remain safe. I love what a Superman moment that was. He isn’t angry he’s dying, he’s angry that he can’t save people anymore.

superman 51 review

So he goes off to see Lana, his oldest friend. I think it’s really important that in a story like this, to showcase Superman’s humanity. To show that even though he may be this dying god, he’s still that kid who grew up on a farm.

Even though the whole “Superman is dying” thing has been done many times, it’s still emotional to hear him talk about where he wants to be buried. You have to love the addition of the Kents in the Fortress now.

We see throughout the issue events of other people. One is trying to hack into the Fortress, and looks to be making her own Superman. Another is of a criminal who gains powers (and a S on his chest). We know that a big part of this arc is about Clark forming his own Super League, to take over when he’s gone. So I’m sure we’ll be seeing a lot more from these people.

And in a very classic Superman moment, we see Clark pay a visit to Lois (Lois and Superman flying together never gets old). This is a relationship that has had its ups and downs over the past 5 years, but for now they’re back to being best friends. He tells Lois that he wants her to tell the world about Clark Kent and Superman.

superman 51 review lois superman panel

Okay so what’s going on? The biggest theory going around right now is that New 52 Superman will be killed off. He will then be replaced by pre-Flashpoint Superman. You know the one we’ve been seeing in Lois & Clark, and the one Dan Jurgens will be writing about in Action Comics come Rebirth.

Now I know a lot of people don’t like New 52 Superman, their Superman is pre-Flashpoint Superman. That’s fair enough. I’m the opposite. I enjoy pre-Flashpoint Superman, but I love New 52 Superman. His character has evolved from an immature and naive guy, to a selfless and inspiring hero. We’ve seen this character grow over 5 years to a point where he is at his peak in terms of characterisation.

He’s not overly powerful, is relatable, and has interesting relationships and stories. And what now? They’re just going to pull the rug out from under us and just replace him? New 52 Superman is the one whose a founding member of the Justice League, is friends with Batman and the rest of the League, worked at the Daily Planet and had his identity revealed to the world. How do you go about just replacing that with a different Superman? (Yes I understand the irony in the situation, but this isn’t a reboot this is having the same universe and just changing the Superman)

superman 51 review spoilers

I don’t mind there being 2 Supermen at the same time. And it is difficult to have them on the same Earth. But there are plenty of Earths out there in the Multiverse that don’t have a Superman. We could have 2 different Superman stories, that aren’t limited by the presence of the other Superman.

I know DC are re-evaluating things that didn’t work in the New 52, and maybe not everyone feels the same way, but I believe the New 52 Superman did work. It may have taken some time, and some creative teams to work out the kinks, but we did get an amazing Superman, let’s not take that away now.

Now of course nothing is permanent in comics so if they do kill him to replace him with the other Superman, New 52 Superman could always come back later. But we can’t keep switching out the 2 different Supermen, it would be confusing and won’t allow for a proper connection with these characters.

I know I’m sounding very defensive right now, but I’m feeling the need to protect my Superman! Obviously with characters who have been around for so long, people resonate with different aspects of the character and the mythos. Why not continue to grow this Superman? Why not commit to this new world you have created and improve upon it?

superman 51 review

Hopefully they don’t outright kill off New 52 Superman, and instead have him maybe be de-powered, hanging around as Clark Kent. Maybe not hanging around as Clark Kent seeing as everyone knows who he is. We know that the New Super-Man (written by Gene Luen Yang) will be absorbing New 52 Superman’s powers. So perhaps instead of death, he’ll have no powers. Which will allow pre-Flashpoint Superman to hang around a while, until the eventual powering up and return of New 52 Superman.

Again this is when things start to get convoluted and weird, but it is comic books so what can you expect?

Right now we really don’t know what’s going to happen, but hopefully all characters are treated with respect.

Need to also mention that the art for Superman #51 was absolutely gorgeous, done by the wonderful Janin. It’s good to see Superman actually look like Superman again!

Overall Superman #51 was an emotional ride that set up the big event that is to come. It’s quiet moments with Lana and Lois which really showcase the kind of character he is. Crossovers can be annoying, I know, but this seems one that will be worth it. You know as long as they don’t kill of my main Supes… 8.2/10

Superman #51
Written by Peter J. Tomasi
Art by Mikel Janin
DC Comics


Categories: comic books

Tagged as: , ,

12 replies »

  1. Damn it, I’m so depressed they are killing off N52 Superman. This guy has really grown a lot since his debut as a naive young kid in Grant Morrisson’s Action Comics. I’m so NOT a fan of Pre-Flashpoint Superman with a kid… especially the shoddy storytelling from Jurgens in Lois and Clark.

    Liked by 1 person

    • It sucks that they’ve spent so long growing the character to shelf him now. Hopefully he won’t be gone permanently, because there are plenty of people who would choose this Superman over Pre-Flashpoint Superman


    • The new 52 superman was different than all other supermen before him. Saying this i’m looking at his character, Lois likes superman not clark, clark kent is who he really is superman is the mask he wears to protect ones he loves. Now clark has always felt different and known that he was, he has no one his equal until he meets wonder woman who has been looking for someone like herself. For me this is the superman i’ve been waiting to see, one not willing to wait on someone to make up their mind but has the ability to decide what he ultimately wants which is now the only one he feels is his eve , diana. This superman can also summon all his power and create a solar flare. This new 52 superman has control of himself, he is different. It’s my hope that he doesn’t languish in the grave too long before someone has the good sense to start his writing his story again. This has been refreshing and my favorite so far especially now that he found the woman he was always meant to be with instead of the ones that always need rescuing and then add nothing else to his story or character. Everything else after New 52 Clark Kent just fills like regurgitated fandom to satisfy someone’s salesplan.


  2. I grew up reading stories of the Pre-Flashpoint Superman, so I like having him around and the son thing is quite new to the canon, so there are potentials there. However I liked the New 52 Superman, I don’t think they should kill him off. Getting rid of the Pre-Flashpoint universe was the mistake. They should had kept both universes alive. I think Pre-Flashpoint Supes should have adventures in his world, while New 52 Supes should remain the hero of his universe. I hope they won’t really kill him off, maybe just take away his powers and make him a human… until the next crisis comes which brings him back to full power.

    It seems to me that Warner/DC doesn’t really know how to handle Superman in any medium.

    Liked by 1 person

    • It would have been great to see both Supermen existing in different stories. It seems like maybe he won’t be killed off, but will just be powerless. Even so, it means we get a different Superman in JL etc, which just seems weird.

      Liked by 2 people

  3. I don’t think DC knows how to handle any of their stuff in any medium lately. Why couldn’t they just simply merge pre-Flashpoint and New 52? It’d keep things fresh while at the same time familiar. For some reason certain New 52 things will still be around, like blackface Wally West, and I don’t see any indication of bringing back the pre-Flashpoint Wally like what they’re doing with Supes, so I don’t even know what the point is of the Rebirth.


  4. I hate everything! Waaaaahhhh! Yeah this story sounds stupid, but most comic stories sound stupid until after you read them. Can I have batman back now please DC? Go away RoboGordon we don’t like your kind here!
    I’ve liked all the new 52 superman stories in his books, JLA x 2 and sup/we book so far.


  5. DC needs to stop rebooting the universe stop killing Superman regardless of whether he is preflash point new 52 or whatever and settle on a Superman once for all . This kill Supes is getting old, tiresome and confusing. And yes Bats is back but only after DC killed again 2 ugh!!!!


    • Well they aren’t rebooting the universe, but yeah it does get annoying with the constant changes. They were just trying to figure out for the longest time what to do, but now it seems like they have more of a long-term plan with Rebirth which is good, even though I’m not sure I like the direction they are going with for Supes


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s